The Great Carbon Credit Debate

Overview

Gabrielle Walker features among many other high level speakers in this TED Countdown film that asks the question, ‘Is there a role for carbon credits in the transition to a fair, net-zero future?’

In June 2022, we travelled to New York to participate in the launch of  the Dilemma Series, created by TED’s climate initiative, Countdown. These events are “designed to look at some of the “knots” in the climate change space, where diverging positions have stalled progress and solidified into an inability to collaborate across differences.”

The New York event revolved around the question, ‘Is there a role for carbon credits in the transition to a fair, net-zero future?’ and presented dozens of TED Talks and conversations featuring scientists, CEOs, activists, politicians, artists, frontline community leaders, investors and more, from which the Countdown team have produced this 36 minute film. It presents “a 360-degree view of carbon credits”.

Audience during TED Countdown Dilemma Session. June 16, 2022, TED World Theater, New York. Photo: Gilberto Tadday / TED

Among those active in the climate space, this is often a difficult conversation that generates  heated debates. With the Dilemma Series, TED have opened up a forum to listen to all sides of those debates and, in this film, they have found a way to identify the commonalities among them, pulling out the threads until they reached “a renewed sense of possibility”.

The clarity this offers to people who agree on the essential nature of the debate but sometimes clash on the details is invaluable. The stumbling blocks are cleared away and the road to progress is reopened. As the Countdown team so eloquently put it, this film presents “an invitation to listen deeply, keep an open mind and get a little wiser on a complex topic”.

The impressive line up of high level speakers features (in order of appearance): Tamara Toles O’Laughlin, John Kilani, Nat Keohane, Julio Friedmann, Donnel Baird, Nili Gilbert, Al Gore, Inés Yábar, James Dyke, Tom Rivett-Carnac, Lindsay Levin, David Biello, Gilles Dufrasne, Kavita Prakash-Mani, Susan Chomba, Gabrielle Walker, Derik Broekhoff and Annette Nazareth.

Click here to watch the film now.

You may also be interested in:

Pioneers in the Global South

Watch the Futures Lab event that got everyone at COP27 talking about carbon removals in Africa - Carbon Removals: Pioneers in the Global South.

Carbon Removals at COP

Introducing Carbon Removals at COP, the online platform dedicated to carbon dioxide removal that has been launched ahead of COP27 Egypt. #CDRatCOP27

Africa Climate Week

African Climate Week starts today and the Rethinking Removals team are on the ground delivering an event on scaling carbon removals.

How carbon credits could actually help fight climate change

Carbon credits should be one of our best tools to fight climate change - if we use them right

Carbon removals: How to distinguish the good, the bad and the very ugly

In June, TED Countdown hosted a Dilemma Session in New York focusing on the role of carbon credits in climate action. Gabrielle Walker and Delia Meth-Cohn of Rethinking Removals joined forces with Julio Friedmann (Carbon Direct) and Eli Mitchell-Larson (Carbon Gap) to design and present a workshop on carbon removals. We were aiming to focus on understanding quality criteria such as additionality and durability - but we started by looking at why we see carbon removals as a source of hope for climate action, not as climate denial or and moral hazard.

Here, Delia takes us through the stages of that event.

Discover the Great Carbon Valley

Social entrepreneur James Mwangi tells us why Africa could be the ideal home for scaling the latest carbon removals technologies to a planetary level

Reimagining carbon removals

At COP26 we ran a UNFCCC Futures Lab on reimagining carbon removals. An amazing group of speakers described their vision of a 2050 future where removals had helped achieve net zero, brought the Global South into the heart of climate action, leveraged the best of nature and tech and complemented robust reduction pathways.

Your guide to carbon removals at COP26

Carbon removal is not on the official agenda at COP26, but it’s being talked about a lot around the edges. We teamed up with our friends at Carbon Removal Advocacy Europe (launching under a new name at COP!) to pull together all the side-events we could find focusing on carbon removals.

Since we need removals to get to net zero, how can we do them right?

No matter how fast we go on reducing emissions, science tells us that we will need to remove carbon on a gigatonne scale to stay within 1.5°C. It's a polarizing topic, but we urgently have to agree on how to tackle this challenge.

TED Talk: Climate healing

In this TED talk, Gabrielle Walker, Director of Valence Solutions and Founder of Rethinking Removals, will explore what it will take to remove carbon from the sky - and do it permanently and at scale, until the climate starts healing.

Getting positive about carbon negative. How do we get removals right?

Carbon removals raises lots of difficult questions. It’s tempting to turn away, but this session will look the issue squarely in the eye and ask: since we need removals to get to net zero, how can we do them right?